The Victims of the Khmer Rouge

Note: This is not my usual lighthearted post about what I saw and what I ate, but it’s a story I feel compelled to share. This is another side of Cambodia.

“To keep you is no benefit, to destroy you is no loss.”
-Khmer Rouge slogan

P1020108

This is what I knew about the Khmer Rouge before coming to Cambodia: Pol Pot, the leader, was very bad; he killed millions of Cambodians in the mid-70s, targeting the educated; people were forced from their homes to work in fields and become “re-educated” or killed; The Killing Fields was an Oscar-winning movie about such atrocities, which I saw many years ago. That pretty much sums it up.

I’ve been to Auschwitz and learned, as many of us have over the years, about the horrors of the holocaust. It’s part of our public consciousness. We learn about it in school, visit museums, read books and watch movies about it- as we absolutely should. We’ve heard survivors say, “We must never forget.” I was even lucky enough to see Elie Wiesel, holocaust survivor and author of Night, speak at my university. As I learned more about the Khmer Rouge and the Cambodian genocide, I realized how little I knew about it. I wondered why the killing of approximately 2 million people (the number varies depending on the source), comprising more than 20% of the country’s population, flew so far under my radar.

The Killing Fields

Less than 10km outside of Phnom Penh lies Choeung Ek, one of the many so-called Killing Fields in operation during the Khmer Rouge regime. It is now a museum where an audio guide directs visitors through the strangely peaceful grounds. More than 100 mass graves dominate the area where 17,000 men, women and children lost their lives between 1975 and 1978. The Khmer Rouge didn’t want to waste bullets on their victims, so most were bludgeoned to death. Bits of bone and cloth can be seen scattered among the earth even today. I walked around with headphones on, in a zombie-like state, trying to wrap my head around what happened there. It’s just something you can’t quite process.

Many victims came to Choeung Ek from the S-21 prison in Phnom Penh.

Mass grave 2- Choeung Ek

One of the many mass graves throughout the grounds

Magic Tree- Choeung  Ek

The “Magic Tree”

Toul Sleng Genocide Museum

The former S-21 prison is now called the Toul Sleng Genocide Museum, and is located in South Phnom Penh. Before it was a prison, it was a high school with adjoining primary school, but Pol Pot took it over in April of 1975 for the detention, interrogation, torture and killing of those suspected of being against the regime. A piece of physical fitness equipment was turned into a torture machine where prisoners were hung upside down until they passed out, after which their heads would be dunked in filthy water to bring them back to consciousness. This helped get false confessions out of the victims about working for the CIA or KGB, organizations many prisoners had never even heard of. Classrooms were turned into torture chambers and holding cells, some made of clumsily thrown-together brick, barely large enough for prisoners to lie down. Crude doorways were created from blasted concrete walls to connect the “classrooms”. My zombie-like state carried me through again, but was broken when seeing the victim’s photos; their innocent faces staring directly at me. Everyone who passed through had their picture taken before being killed at S-21 or meeting their fate at Choeung Ek. The rows upon rows of men, women, children and even entire families seemed never ending.

Torture device in foreground, building in background- Tuol Sleng

Torture device with dunking pots and one of the buildings in background

Barbed wire- Tuol Sleng

Barbed wire kept them in

Torture room- Tuol Sleng

Torture room

Makeshift cells- Tuol Sleng

Brick cells

Doorways- Tuol Sleng

Doorway

The Survivors

It was towards the end of my Tuol Sleng visit, while in a complete daze, that I saw a man sitting at a table with a banner claiming he was a survivor of S-21. I knew from my visit that only seven people were believed to have survived, so could he really be one of them? I walked over and a woman explained that he did indeed make it out of S-21, and would I like to buy his book for $10? Whoa, wait a minute. Here sat a man who endured the tortures of this place, and he returns to sell his story? After everything I had just seen, it was too much to take. Heartbroken, I bought his book, took a photo and left with tears in my eyes. When my friend Natalia and I got back to our hotel I asked her, “Why don’t we know about this guy?” He is one of SEVEN survivors, yet I’ve never seen a 60 Minutes segment or even heard about his story. And he’s selling his book in the very place he was subjected to such brutality in order to support his family?! I was mad.

Bou Meng- at table at Tuol Sleng

Bou Meng at his table

Natalia and I went to Siem Reap, and then to Sihanoukville, and then back to Phnom Penh. She left, and I kept thinking about Bou Meng, this man I briefly met. I had to go back. So I paid my $2 entrance fee and walked directly to his spot, where he was again sitting. There were a few people around him so I asked if anyone spoke English. I said I wanted to talk to Bou Meng and just ask him a few questions. No English from anyone. I watched as people simply walked past him, not knowing the historical treasure who sat feet away. Then I turned and saw another table. It was Chum Mey, the other survivor. These two men are the only living prisoners and they are both peddling their stories to people passing by. I asked the woman next to Chum Mey if she spoke English. She was able to tell me his book was $10, and that was about it. Ok, another $10 it is, so I collected my book and left.

Chum Mey- Tuol Sleng

Chum Mey in his spot

What kept these men alive? For Chum Mey, he was singled out for his ability to repair the typewriters used at the prison. Bou Meng was an artist, and was asked to paint several portraits of Pol Pot. The first one he painted was compared against the original photo for accuracy. If the slightest difference was detected, he would’ve been killed. Bou Meng was brought to the prison with his wife, who he never saw after they were separated that first day. Years later when he revisited the prison, he looked for the photo that was taken of her upon arrival. Today he keeps a copy with him as it’s the only remaining image he has of her. Chum Mey witnessed his wife and newborn son killed with assault rifles in a rice field.

After exploring the northeast, I returned to Phnom Penh again and thoughts of Bou Meng and Chum Mey still swirled in my head. I just couldn’t let it go, so I went back a third time. Bou Meng was at lunch, as was Chum Mey. I asked the woman at Bou Meng’s table if she spoke English. “A little,” she replied. I said I just wanted to talk to Bou Meng for a few minutes. Honestly, I didn’t know what I was doing there or what I wanted to ask. I just felt I needed more. So I waited, and while I did, I asked her some questions. I found out she was his niece and spent most days there with Bou Meng, helping him sell his book. He and Chum Mey are now friends, but didn’t know each other when they were imprisoned. They are the last living survivors of S-21. Bou Meng used to live in the countryside and would travel to Phnom Penh occasionally, but he recently moved to the city so he could sell his book full time. Tuol Sleng is the only place you can buy it as it’s self-published, evident by the shoddy photocopy job. Such a shame.

Bou Meng returned from lunch. I knew he was a small man when I first met him, but watching him walk down the sidewalk, I realized he couldn’t be more than 5 feet tall. I didn’t want to take too much time away from selling his book, so I kept it short. I asked what he wanted people to know about his story. Through his translator niece, this is what he said:

“I want people to know what happened to me. That I didn’t make any mistake. I didn’t know anything about the CIA or KGB. I didn’t do anything wrong. I am a painter. I am a painter.” He continued, “I want people to learn about the genocide. I hope no more people are killed without reason. I want justice for the past and the present.”

Pretty simple requests. He made a point of conveying that there’s a place in this world for punishment as a consequence for wrong doing, but what happened to him was not that. It was unjust and unwarranted.

At $10 a pop he and Chum Mey are probably eking out a decent living by Cambodian standards, but the fact that they need to sit THERE to do it feels so wrong. And the biggest tragedy is that these men won’t be around for much longer, yet their stories have only been heard by a relative few. I don’t have a large platform, but I can share a small piece of their lives with you. It’s the very least I can do.

Not a whole lot is available on these two men. There is a compelling documentary called S-21: The Khmer Rouge Killing Machine in which Chum Mey and Van Nath (S-21 survivor, now deceased) are featured along with their captors, which won several awards. There is also a NY Times article about the Khmer Rouge tribunal that reports a bit about them both. Thankfully they lived to see “Duch”, the S-21 commander, receive a life sentence for his crimes, although that didn’t come to pass until 2012 (after the initial 2010 sentence of 19 years was overturned). That’s a long time to wait for justice.

“Injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere”
– Martin Luther King, Jr.

Bou Meng and Shelley Graner

Me with Bou Meng

Chum Mey and Shelley Graner

Me with Chum Mey

Advertisements

26 thoughts on “The Victims of the Khmer Rouge

  1. Pingback: To Asia, With Love (and Other Emotions) | Plans Subject to Change

  2. That´s a history so sadly and so terribly … almost not learned in my country… Shelley, I am sure that more that for the value of the book this man felt gratitude towards you for having been interested in his history… Will All the persons happen daily for this place as one more walk? It is necessary a pure, nice and attentive heart to see what it was not possible to write or show… I believe that though you could never have spoken with him across another person his heart understand you because you were returning again and again and the pure souls always said things that we can´t explain… I had luck of having known yourself … you are a great person!!!

  3. Thanks again, Shelley. Another bedtime “story” with Sophia. Perhaps it’s an atrocity to profit from such evil. But like you mentioned, at $10/ book, they are probably comfortable. I want to think they are there for a bigger purpose…. letting the world know what happened and what can happen again. Travel safe and take cAre!

    • I love that you shared this with Sophie! And yes, I think they are here to tell their story… I just wish they had a larger platform so more people could learn and understand what happened.

  4. I love your writings and remember the horrible stories that were in the L. A. Times and many other journals. Television was all over this horrible war. I would love to donate to their cause, is there a way for that to happen? Also, of what language are the books written?

    • Kind of you to say, Nancy, thank you. Unfortunately they don’t have a sophisticated system in place for donating money (that I could find). The books are translated into English, but are only available at the museum in Phnom Penh. Sadly, they don’t make helping them very easy. If I find anything, I will let you know.

  5. You have proven yourself to be a talented writer of wit and compassion. This is the most beautiful and touching piece you’ve written, full of pathos and humanity. Through it all your good and noble heart shines through. I’m so deeply proud of you.

  6. I never made it to Tuol Sleng, but I went to the Killing Fields last month. Not everyone likes to hear about that side of my trip, and many people aren’t even aware of what happened – it’s great to get it out there. Great post Shelley. x

  7. Wonderful story- beautiful and horrible. I’ll never forget when we saw the wall of shoes at Auschwitz. Good work raising awareness of the Cambodian genocide.

  8. Wow what a powerful story. Shelley, you are making a differance in this world. You tell an amazing story. What can I do to help you help them?

    • Many thanks, Linda. I wish I knew what more could be done! Unfortunately they don’t make it very easy since their books aren’t available outside the museum and there isn’t an easy “donate” button for us all to push. I will continue to look, though, and let you know what I find.

  9. I am in tears as I read this. I have been to S-21 and the Killing Fields and this is such a tragedy. I cannot believe this happened in my lifetime. thank you for continuing to remind us that we all have responsibility to shine light on the injustice in the world.

  10. Wow – this is the second time I’ve heard about this from you and I’m even more affected than the first time. So beautifully written. And so great that you’re making sure more people know about this.

  11. I’m having trouble seeing through my tears as I write this….is there any way we can purchase their books to help support them? I, for one, would so gladly do so. Thank you for sharing this, Shelley.

    • Susan, one of the most frustrating things is that they make it VERY hard to support them! There is no organization that accepts donations for them (that I’ve found), and their books aren’t available outside the museum. If I find anything out, I will definitely let you know!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s